A document I missed, a twofold annoyance, and a retraction

Cardinal Arinze


A document I missed

Many thanks to TD who emailed me to point out that the question of uniformity of posture after Holy Communion has actually been dealt with by the Congregation for Divine Worship. Cardinal George, O.M.I., Chairman of the US Bishops Committee on the Liturgy, sent a Dubium to the CDW and received a response from the Prefect, Cardinal Arinze. Here is the text, courtesy of EWTN:
5 June 2003

Prot. n. 855/03/L

Dubium: In many places, the faithful are accustomed to kneeling or sitting in personal prayer upon returning to their places after individually received Holy Communion during Mass. Is it the intention of the Missale Romanum, editio typica tertia, to forbid this practice?

Responsum: Negative, et ad mentem. The mens is that that the prescription of the Institutio Generalis Missalis Romani, no. 43, is intended, on one hand, to ensure within broad limits a certain uniformity of posture within the congregation for the various parts of the celebration of the Holy Mass, and on the other, to not regulate posture rigidly in such  a way that those who wish to kneel or sit would no longer be free.

Francis Cardinal Arinze
Prefect
The other day I wrote about the instruction that is given in some places, for all the members of the congregation to remain standing after Holy Communion until everyone has received - and therefore to forbid people from kneeling or sitting.

It is important to note that the above response is not simply an instruction for the Church in the USA, but gives the mens (lit. "mind" or better, "thinking" or "reasoning") of the Holy See concerning the matter. This reasoning is that the General Instruction of the Roman Missal does not intend to impose a rigid uniformity of posture such that people who want to sit or kneel would not be free to do so.

A twofold annoyance

I am annoyed for two reasons.

1. I should have either known or found out about this ruling. I didn't. So I made a mistake and that is always annoying, but it is good for humility.

2. Given this ruling and explanation, no Bishop should forbid his people from kneeling after Holy Communion or send liturgical experts to the parishes to give instructions to people to observe what the CDW calls a "rigid uniformity." It is annoying at a deeper level that some Bishops still do this.

The bottom line, then, is that if you are ordered by your parish priest, roaming liturgical expert, or Bishop, to stand after Holy Communion until everyone else has received, you do not have to obey the instruction because they do not have the authority to override the Congregation for Divine Worship.

A Retraction

In my post 3 (slightly ranty) suggestions for when you are ordered to stand until everyone has received Holy Communion I said the following:
Must a lay person obey such an instruction? Reluctantly, I suppose we must concede that the Bishop or parish priest does have the authority to instruct people as to their bodily posture at the modern rite of Mass, since the General Instruction of the Roman Missal provides for such instruction.
I retract that statement. I should have said the following:
Must a lay person obey such an instruction? No. the Bishop or parish priest does not have the authority to forbid people from kneeling or sitting after Holy Communion since the Holy See has specifically responded to a Dubium on the question, stating that this is not the intention of n.43 of the General Instruction of the Roman Missal.
I have now updated the post.

The question arose on Twitter in a general thread on obedience which then focussed on this question. The example given was from Canada. Therefore it is relevant also to reference a post by Vox Cantoris in 2012: Apostolic Nuncio to Canada on Kneeling after Communion. The blog author wrote to the Apostolic Nuncio and received a reply (which can be seen in the article) referring him to the Dubium and response quoted above.








Popular posts from this blog

1962 Missal pdf online

The Church Music Association of America and Jeffrey Tucker of the New Liturgical Movement have made available the 1962 Missal online in pdf format (72Mb). The file is hosted at Musica Sacra , the website of the CMAA, thanks to a generous gift from Fr Robert Skeris While you are at it, take a look at the articles clarifying the rules for music at Low Mass and music at High Mass .
Read more

Święcone - blessing of Easter food

Image
The blessing of meat, eggs and bread at the end of Lent is a Catholic tradition that has been preserved by the Polish people. A Polish family in my parish asked to bless their baskets of food (containing these items) on Holy Saturday so I arranged to do so at 11am, letting others know also. Above you can see a basket ( Święcone ) that was prepared as a gift for me. When I was asked to do this blessing by another Polish family a couple of years ago, I was intrigued to find that in my 1860 copy of the Roman Ritual ( above ), there is, precisely, a blessing of lamb, eggs and bread for Holy Saturday. This convinced me that the devotion kept by the Poles must have been something more widely practised in past centuries. The immediate explanation might be that this is the blessing of food at the end of the Lenten fast. It must be more than that. People would have abstained from meat, and from lacticinia (including eggs) but not from bread. Perhaps there is a more specifically eucharis
Read more

Beachy Head and Lewes

Image
We did manage to visit Beachy Head yesterday on the way over to Shoreham-on-Sea. It was a good blustery English summer's day which added to the experience of walking near the edge of the highest coastal chalk cliff in Britain. Above is one of the photos I took. I might get a chance to stitch together a YouTube video about the site. Fr Sean Finnegan (of the Valle Adurni blog) was, as ever, a magnificent host, not only setting us up for our Masses but also giving us an excellent lunch. He has posted an amusing lament on the subject of his Church: Oh Lord! A prayer . Today, we took the train to Lewes to visit Fr Richard Biggerstaff at the parish of St Pancras. Fr Jonathan Martin is staying with him during the summer. Below, you can see the fine Church; thankfully, the Ditchling altar has survived various phases of "re-ordering". I realised today that I love serving Mass in the usus antiquior as well as saying it. I served Fr Briggs' Mass after saying my own and tried t
Read more

SPUC Clergy information day

Image
SPUC today held a Clergy Information Day. Unfortunately, because of an urgent meeting I had to be late for this so I missed the first half of the morning lecture by Fr John Fleming. I could catch up with most of it from his notes and look forward to the published version when it is available from SPUC. Fr Fleming was speaking about the rights of the unborn under international law, the pro-life battle at the UN and the nature of the early human embryo. As a lecture, it was certainly not "dumbed down". He presented some of the latest research on the biochemistry of the human embryo in relationship with the mother and then tied this in to the philosophical question of the status of the embryo, dealing with such hoary chestnuts as twinning and the differentiation of cells in the embryo. It was a most helpful and informative presentation: intellectually challenging but well put together. I think that the sheer quality of these presentations has been the important factor in the gr
Read more

When people walk away with Holy Communion

Image
It happens from time to time that someone will come up for Holy Communion which they receive into their hands, and then walk away with the sacred host. A priest friend asked me to write something about what we can do. Let’s think first of all of the actual situation and then about some possible preventative measures. In terms of canon law, the desecration of the sacred species is a crime, punishable by automatic excommunication. In most cases, the person does not know what they are doing or how wrong it is, so I’ll assume that is the case (rather than deliberate desecration, perhaps for satanic purposes or as an atheistic stunt.) But even if the person does not know the seriousness of what they are doing, it is still objectively a very grave matter. So we can’t just let it happen. A pastoral complication is that people don’t like to be “shown up” or embarrassed in front of the congregation so they can easily become annoyed or aggressive in their confusion. Therefore we need to ke
Read more