Pages

Monday, 28 November 2011

When legal positivism meets anti-clericalism

How's this for stupid lawsuit of the year? Johannes Christian Sundermann, a lawyer from Unna in North Rhine Westphalia, representing a man from Dortmund, has filed a legal complaint against the pope for not wearing a seat belt on several occasions “for more than one hour at a time” during his visit to Freiburg at the end of September.

Apparently the lawyer (a member of the socialist Left party) took the case on after several other lawyers refused to do so. If he is doing the case pro bono, I hope it takes up a lot of his time. If he is not, then "man from Dortmund" may learn a salutary lesson.

The report in The Local (Germany's News in English) tells us that "both Sundermann and his client are no longer members of the Catholic Church." No surprise there, then. (Though of course they are still members of the Catholic Church whether they like it or not.)

6 comments:

Fortiter Pugnem said...

If His Holiness can get sued for this, then surely President Obama can get impeached for saying "Let's kick some a&&!" Or the First Lady for not being proud of her country until her husband was elected president.
Great! I though that this was considered a traffic offense- it turns out to be another way to get money out of famous people! Hollywood, look out!

A. Nicot said...

Unless of course they went to "deregister" themselves with their bishop.

I've read about this elsewhere as well. It's just absurd.

colmcille2 said...

It's the teutonic sense of humour...

archie wedderspoon said...

Just how does Sundermann propose to get round the fact that the Holy Father is the head of another state? I thought that under the law of nations that was impossible.

Fr Tim Finigan said...

A. Nicot - "de-registering" does not unbaptise a person. They are still Catholics de facto if not de iure civili

Hughie said...

Archie Wedderspoon is, of course, perfectly correct. The Holy Father was in Germany on an official "State Visit" travelling on a Vatican City State diplomatic passport and NOT his German one (which he still retains).

As the Head of State of Vatican City State, under international law, and the Rules of the Court of St James, he cannot be pursued before the German courts, civil or criminal, as he was and is entitled to both diplomatic and sovereign immunity.

This is nothing more nor less than another ludicrous publicity stunt.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...