Pages

Thursday, 27 September 2007

"Diverse Sensibilities"

Dr Peter Wright has drawn attention in the combox to the masterful phrase of Bishop Giuseppe Bertori, secretary-general of the Italian bishops' conference. Sua Eccelenza denied that some bishops had called for a more restrictive interpretation of "Summorum Pontificum" but allowed that,
ci sono state sensibilità diverse, cioè più attente all’una o all’altra dimensione pastorale dell’applicazione del testo...

there were diverse sensibilities, that is to say, more attentive to one or other pastoral dimension of the application of the text
The English-speaking world is familiar with the classic examples of how politicians have avoided calling each other liars by using saying that there the other party was "economical with the truth" of guilty of a "terminological inexactitude". (Apparently, Churchill's first use of this phrase was quite innocent.)

Henceforth on this blog let us avoid ever saying that prelates have disagreed flatly with each other or the Pope or whoever. Perish the thought! Instead, let us say that there were "diverse sensibilities more attentive to one or other pastoral (or other) dimension."

We could have some fun bringing other diplomatic circumlocutions into use.

4 comments:

John said...

Diverse sensibilities...!
I really liked that.
I may well use it myself in the future.
Thanks Father!

JARay

Auricularius said...

Diplomatic Circumlocutions

1. Ordained Ministry /Priesthood

2. Pastoral Solution /A means of circumventing the moral law

3. Vision Statement /We don’t know what we’re talking about

4. Sisters & Brothers /I’ve got a guilt complex about being a man

5. Parish Cluster
/We’re desperate but don’t want to admit it

6. Tridentine /Evil or Old-Fashioned

7. Collaborative Ministry /Priest: know your place

8. Trained Liturgist /Fool

9. Eucharistic Minister /See No 5

10. Collegial /See No 7

Dr. Peter H. Wright said...

In 1969, the newly appointed American ambassador, Walter H. Annenberg, was at Buckingham Palace to present his credentials to the Queen.

The BBC cameras were there to record the event as part of a TV film about the Queen.

They recorded the following conversation :

Her Majesty :
"Where are you living now ?"

His Excellency :
"We are at present living in the
ambassador's residence subject of course to some discomfiture as a result of the need for certain elements of refurbishment and rehabilitation."

("We've got the decorators in, so the place is a bit of a mess.")
My translation.

Catholicus said...

Pastoral, read 'clerical'

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...