Pages

Sunday, 8 July 2007

Some links for Summorum Pontificum

Just for your convenience, I have gathered a few links related to Summorum Pontificum.

TEXT
Summorum Pontificum - official Latin text on the Vatican website.

Translation of Summorum Pontificum - on the Vatican website but labelled "unofficial."

The Holy Father's accompanying letter - English version on the Vatican website.

New Catholic at Rorate Caeli has produced a pdf of the text of Summorum Pontificum and the English translation in parallel columns.

COMMENTARY
Fr John Zuhlsdorf has some helpful and sensible introductory comments

Shawn Tribe at the New Liturgical Movement has a Brief Summary of the Pre and Post MP Scenarios which I think sums up a lot of important points - especially his summary:
Overall, the significant, general shift in the post-MP Church is of course the de-marginalization of the Roman liturgical tradition and a re-assertion of a hermeneutic of continuity.
There are several other excellent posts on the New Liturgical Movement which offer informed and balanced commentary. Others have simply put a link to say something like "see informed commentary here" - a just recognition of the excellent quality of information and comment at that first class blog.

Fr John Boyle has a commentary with the insight and expertise of an experienced canon lawyer.

Fr Martin Fox has some good observations in his post Well, the pope done did it!. From the point of view of the "hermeneutic of continuity" I particularly like his summary:
This is about how the Church, and history, views Vatican II--and that's big This should signal it's time to stop using the "new v. old" Church and Mass way of explaining Vatican II. Sorry, that's both incorrect and now it's clearly unhelpful. The pope--the pope--is saying that's wrong. I know, a lot of us were told that, and on behalf of those who told you that, wearing a collar--I'm sorry. But the time has now arrived to stop.
Sandro Magister: Benedict XVI Liberalizes the Ancient Rite of the Mass – And Explains WhyAs ever, he shows how to do religious journalism with accuracy and insight.

Phil Lawler give the Catholic World News analysis.

The Committee on the Liturgy of the US Conference of Catholic Bishops has obviously taken the opportunity given by the advance release of the document to the Bishops. In their Newsletter dated June-July 2007 just published, they have the English text of the Motu Proprio itself and the accompanying letter. They then have 20 questions on the letter itself, including a comparison of Summorum Pontificum with Quattuor Abhinc Annos and Ecclesia Dei Adflicta, and 10 questions on the ordinary and extraordinary forms of the Missale Romanum. There are one or two things to quibble with (the comparison of old and new rites especially) but it rather puts us to shame over here.

16 comments:

Mrs Jackie Parkes MJ said...

Fr. why are people already moaning about it?

J said...

Father, you may have already seen that RORATE CÆLI have produced a very good .pdf document of Summorum Pontificum with a side by side comparison of the Latin/English rather like a missal. https://www.blogger.com/comment.g?blogID=25543378&postID=2431208394477771376

Fr Tim Finigan said...

J - thanks, just found that before I saw your comment and added it to the post.

Jackie - SP is quite an earth-shattering document and will upset some people who have lived with a different way of thinking for many years - you know, "old church, new church". So we can expect some howling but must be peacemakers in the spirit of our wonderful Pope.

Mrs Jackie Parkes MJ said...

Yes Fr, but it's not the modern ones i've noticed moaning!

Lee Gilbert said...

See also http://www.summorumpontificum.net/

Nancy said...

Here in Canada we're not too far behind the mother country - nothing from our bishops' conference.

Fr John Boyle said...

With you in spirit with all those celebrations. Thanks for putting such a convenient list of references, and for linking to me. God bless.

Anonymous said...

Thank you for these great links Father - now I shall get no work done at all for ages....

Amette

Karen H. -- San Diego, Ca. said...

Fr.Tim, THANK YOU so much for putting pointers to all these links together...that was a lot of work on your part. My own priest will be happy that I can pass him an html link to this particular blog.

He likes to read all the documents in the originally Latin when available. And this will be a big help. I'll
drop him an email next.

Again, many thanks.

Anonymous said...

Dear father,
it seems that the motu proprio does not mention holy orders and communion "extra missam" as cases of lawful use of the classical liturgy. Neither does it mention sacramentals, e.g. blessings.
Is that correct?
Is there a special reason for this?
Might we extend the permission to these cases for a sort of analogy or "epieikeia"?
Thank you.
Thomas

Fr Tim Finigan said...

On blessings, and Holy Communion ourside of Mass, the authorisation to use the older Rituale Romanum covers these, I think.

Interesting that ordinations are not mentioned. The FSSP and ICRSS use the old rite of ordination. I think that if a Bishop were to ask, he would not be refused.

Lee Gilbert said...

Also, see this:

http://forums.catholic.com/forumdisplay.php?f=115

John Kearney said...

I am delighted that so many priests are celebrating the Motus Proprio. Meanwhile in Basingstoke, in the diocese of Portsmouth we have a war on our hands trying to save the abandoned Church of the HOly Ghost. Look in on my blog. I have I believe paved the way with some of the parishioners for a priest to occupy one of the flats the Presbytery is being converted into. It could be the right place to take a stand beside the Motus Proprio flag. Or maybe not. But I want a priest who is free and will battle with the bishop to win the post. Pray for us.

Lee said...

I think it's going to be quite difficult for the clergy and laity to change the mindset from the current 'ad hoc experimental' mentality of the novus ordo, to the 'tried and tested' old rite - not only spiritually but also practically. For instance, how will priests prevent a pollution of the old rite (e.g. when an altar girl wants to serve, or when the laity come to communion standing up and wanting Our Lord in the hand?).

I note that there are some Benedictine Monks in England that seem to offer a whole section of motu proprio applicable aids:

http://www.theabbeyshop.com/index.php?cPath=72

I'm excited.

Fr Tim Finigan said...

Many thanks for that link, Lee.

As to pollution of the old rite - I would rather focus on the improvement of the new rite. This is made much easier by seismic shift of emphasis made possible by Summorum Pontificum.

Richard Brown said...

Just to let you know that CTS has published Summorum Pontificum

http://www.cts-online.org.uk/Vatican_documents.htm

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...